Wednesday, May 1, 2013

Should Organized Labor Return to its May Day Roots?

Heart of the Beast Theater celebrates May Day in Minneapolis Photo Credit: Minnesota Public Radio
In honor of May Day, here's a great quote by Rad Geek (via Roderick Longcritically evaluating the current incarnation of the holiday:
"May Day is a celebration of the original conception of the labor movement, as expressed by anarchist organizers such as Albert Parsons, Lucy Parsons, Benjamin Tucker, and others: a movement for workers to come into their own, by banding together, supporting one another, and taking direct action in the form of boycotts, work stoppages, general strikes, and the creation of workers' spaces such as local co-operatives and union hiring halls. The spirit was best expressed by John Brill's famous exhortation to "Dump the bosses off you back"--by which he did not mean to go to a government mediator and get them to make the boss sit down with you and work out a slightly more beneficial arrangement. "Dump the bosses off you back!" meant: organize and create local institutions that let you bypass the bosses. Negotiate with them if it'll do some good; ignore them if it won't. The signal achievements of the labor movement in the late 19th and early 20th century were achievements in this spirit: the campaigns that won the 8 hour day and the weekend off in many workplaces, for example, emerged from a unilateral work stoppage by rank-and-file workers, declared by the Federation of Organized Trades and Labor Unions, and organized especially by the explicitly anarchist International Working People's Association, after legislative efforts by the National Labor Union and the Knights of Labor failed. The stagnant, or even backsliding, state of organized labor over the past half century is the direct result of government colonization and the ascendancy of government-subsidized unions.
This is a pretty harsh public choice story about the recent history of the labor movement: gains in legitimacy and state support have backfired by opening up new opportunities for special interests (i.e. capitalists) to seize control over the levers of power, constraining labor's freedom to demonstrate and fight. Although this seems undeniably true, it's probably not the whole story concerning labor's decline (technology & globalization mattered, for example), and it almost certainly undervalues the social benefits of widespread access to safe, stable channels for airing labor disputes. Increasing organized labor's capacity for radical action would almost certainly see a concurrent response from businesses in the form of more capricious firing and workforce intimidation.


  1. It would be interesting to compare inflation adjusted wages and benefits and lifestyle of the average pre-union-movement factory worker in the 19th century with the present day non-union burger flipper (who probably has an iphone, clean clothes, and an automobile with air-conditioning).

  2. Hіt 'copy' from windows XP аnd tried to paste
    into andrоіd. I oughta quit life.

    Herе іs my ωеb-ѕіte: best tenant loans

  3. In my view, there's no point getting out of bed for less than a grand, so this doesn't lοoκ as thοugh it's worth it to me.

    my webpage; best fast cash loans

  4. Off foг a scan on my fingers, can ardly tyре with thiѕ
    . Rly hard typing wіth a fractuгeԁ forefingeг!

    Vіsit my webрage best value loans

  5. Perfect introduction, madе me reаd the whole
    pοst. Mine alωays seem to waffle on, уours is nicе and effectiѵe.

    Μу homeρage: best personal loans

  6. Aωesome issues here. I'm very glad to peer your article. Thanks a lot and I am looking forward to contact you. Will you please drop me a e-mail?

    Here is my website :: best loans for bad credit

  7. I purсhasеd a сomparable domаin to
    this last weеk, I'm hoping to add something a little different to the subject.

    My web site best personal loans

  8. If уou aге doing іt too thеn I'm not doing it! There's no point doing thе same thing again.

    My wеbsite -

  9. Thіs has mаԁe me ρondeг if there's a couple of places I could do things a bit better.

    Here is my web site ... personal Loans bad credit

  10. I'm wondering at what age we begin to get more grown up and take no notice of all this nonsense.

    Take a look at my blog post - Personal loans

  11. Until a fгіend told me about it I hadn't even realized it possible. Seems like I'm way behind οn the matter.

    Feel fгee to surf to mу ωebpаge:
    best personal loans